In this chapter from his book Great Commission Conundrums, Jon Nelms, founder of Final Frontiers Foundation, questions who sets missionary support levels in each country, and why novice missionaries raise as much as veterans. Reading time: about 20 minutes.
Failure sometimes comes from seeking answers to well-established practices and questions, but so do successes.
Explaining the Conundrum: Explaining Missionary Support Levels
This two-part conundrum will probably surprise most of you, and by most, I mean anyone who is not a missionary. Even missionaries tend to take these questions as absolute and dare not seek an answer. They are as fixed as the law of gravity and, thus, are seldom questioned. We don’t jump off tall buildings, and we don’t ask questions like these, as either could bring us to a swift and definite end.
I combine the two questions because they overlap, and I ask these questions because I have nothing to lose. I don’t have a mission board to answer to—just a board of directors of the ministry I founded in 1986. They, like me, tend to ask hard questions in the hope of finding answers. Failure sometimes comes from seeking answers to well-established practices and questions, but so do successes.
Someone once got tired of walking and made a wheel. Naysayers must have mocked him and asked, “What are you going to do with that thing?” That question made him think, “I don’t know, but it was so much fun, I think I’ll make a second one.” When his friends saw him making a second wheel, they must have rightly surmised, “If one wheel is a failure, then two wheels is a double failure.” The humble inventor eventually figured out that he could move without walking by joining the two with an axle and putting a platform on it, or so he thought. It worked great going downhill but not so great going uphill. That’s probably when the word “push” was invented. Then a brainstorm persuaded him to attach a horse and now he had a cart that revolutionized transportation. His necessity to push soon became the horse’s mandate to pull, and all he had to do was sit and enjoy the ride.
This plan worked well for thousands of years until a few years back, someone without a horse, or disgusted with the cost of feeding them and the mess they left in the streets, invented an engine. And the rest is (more recent) history.
It is true that failures sometimes come from asking well-established questions, but so do successes. So, let’s take a risk and ask.
Examining the Conundrum
These are good questions asked by many pastors and laypeople, so I decided to research and see what I could learn. First, I wanted to separate the financing of denominational missionaries from that of faith missionaries. The following points list some differences in the two types given in the most general of terms.
A denominational missionary is one who the denomination’s mission division hires. He is an employee who receives a salary and various compensations. He does not have to go on deputation, raise support, or answer to individual churches. Generally, once hired, he is quickly sent to his field of service to do whatever his denomination tells him to do. His calling is determined by them—not necessarily by the Lord’s direction. He may want to plant churches but is assigned to run a youth camp. Financially, he is well taken care of and provided with lodgings, vehicles, insurance, household servants, etc. Typically, he will be given a furlough every fifth year and return to America where he is NOT required or expected to speak in churches. He is to rest for the year and then return to the field or move on to his new assignment.
A faith missionary must raise his support and generally does not receive the perks of the denominational missionary. He is his own boss and can-do whatever ministry he feels led by Christ to do, wherever that may take him. His support is dependent on the faithfulness of those who pledged it. When he returns home for furlough, there is no rest at all. He and his family travel from one supporting church to another, giving updates on their work and trying to squeeze in new churches to gain additional support. The initial raising of support can take from one to five years. Usually, if not raised by that time, the missionary assumes he misunderstood God’s will and resigns his title and serves as a pastor or faithful church member.
I want to begin by addressing the denominational missionary’s situation if for no other reason, to make the reader more informed and make the faith missionary a little jealous. None of us want to give up our autonomy, yet the thought of having immediate, full support with perks, and having no deputation, no financial stress, no wearing two or more hats since they work with teams—each man having his own job and a year off with pay every five years—is very tempting. So, let me begin with examining the denominational missionary and then spend the bulk of my time in my world, that of the faith missionary.
Online at thenest.com, I found an article by Dana Severson entitled “The Average Missionary Salary.” The photo caption accompanying it stated: “The average salary for missionaries is relatively low.” Here’s a breakdown of what I discovered, all stats being relevant to 2012. As you continue, note that the article addresses missionaries who are sent by an organization (they are employees), as opposed to “faith missionaries” (those who have to raise their support).
Supported denominational missionary couples received on average $121,000 a year, but the Bureau of Labor Statistics stated that the average salary was a low $30,650. That’s because, due to additional other subsidies, the “salary” was only equal to 47 percent of the “income.” So, what else is included in the non-salary income? Are you ready?
- $6,050 per couple if living in areas where the cost of living is higher than in the USA. What? Well, keep in mind that among Baptists, about 20 percent of our missionaries (over 570 of them) live in Europe, where things are likely more expensive. There are 112 missionary couples who live in the United Kingdom alone and 104 in Canada. There are 68 missionary families in Japan; I can’t imagine how expensive that must be. Then, of course, there are 77 in Australia and 29 in New Zealand. (I would have thought they already had the gospel, but since most churches and people define a missionary as being a pastor preaching anywhere other than at home, it makes sense to call them missionaries.)
- $10,000 housing subsidies are necessary since many career missionaries maintain a house in the USA while living overseas.
- $8,500 per couple was allocated for travel expenses.
- $10,890 was an allotment to cover medical expenses.
- $8,470 per year was designated for administrative expenses (presumedly, this is for the mission board that handles their accounts).
- $8,470 for other incidentals (?)
- $7,260 for pensions
- $4,840 for taxes
I want to ask the question here that I think all missionaries, if honest, would ask, “Where do I sign up for this job?”
Thinking that this report must be an exaggeration, I looked further. That’s when I found an EFCA article by Daryl Anderson of ReachGlobal (year unknown), stating that “The average cost to support a missionary family from North America is $10,338 per month.” (That’s $124,056 annually.) It continued, “However, support needs range from a low of $4,000 a month ($48,00 annually) up to $16,000” ($192,000 annually) depending on family size, location, start-up costs, etc.
Well, that makes sense, I guess. The nebulous “start-up costs” were defined as travel and vehicle purchase, maintenance, and relocation—you know, the same kind of expenses that the ordinary person who buys a car, takes a trip, or moves to another location has to incur. And I forgot, it also includes the cost of a computer. These are all needed and legitimate expenses. Still, you have to seriously question the need for such funding when you realize missionaries don’t have to ship their belongings since furniture and appliances can be purchased anywhere. And as for travel, you can sometimes fly from Atlanta to Budapest, Beirut, Tokyo, Paris, Rome, London, or Manila, cheaper than you can fly from Atlanta to Seattle.
As I read further, I saw the list contained a line item that I found particularly curious entitled, “Readiness Evaluation and Pre-Field Training.” The title alone seems to imply that you may not pass muster, and if not, then what happens to all the support you raised and the years it took to raise it? Shouldn’t your readiness be determined, and your training be finished BEFORE you set out to raise support? No corporate executive would hire a man and give him a title and a considerable salary, hoping that he performs well. That’s why internships were invented. Corporate headhunters seek experienced men with a resume. So, why do we treat God’s work in this way?
Organizational and denominational missionaries earn far more than your typical “faith” missionary. Still, in fairness to them, I have heard that some graciously share their salaries with poorer missionaries who lack support. And since I am assuming that most of the readers will be involved in faith missions, let me approach the issues from that viewpoint.
Exposing the Conundrum
When I was younger, I learned that mission boards set the support amount based on what country the missionary was called to, and their determination is made based on the pay scale of a certain level of the US Embassy staff in that country. This is why someone going to France is required to raise more funding than someone going to Jamaica. Frankly, you would have to survey each faith mission board to learn how they determine support levels. Wisely, all either recommend or require the missionary to be debt-free before departing.
Most missionaries never mention the amount of funding they are trying to raise; they are taught to refer to percentages rather than to amounts. That way, they don’t have to answer those embarrassing questions like, “Why do you need so much?” When asked amounts rather than percentages, potential-supporting-pastors often comment, “That’s nearly twice what I make!” To be honest, we missionaries are embarrassed about the amount we are trying to raise. Most of us will make more as a missionary than we ever did in the pastorate or business. Few will take a pay cut. This becomes incredibly embarrassing when we realize that we will likely be making more than the president of the country in which we will live—if it’s a developing nation. You quickly learn why it is better to talk in terms of percentages rather than amounts when someone like me comes along, reminding churches that the average national preacher in the land where the missionary is going earns only one-tenth or one one-hundredth of what the average missionary earns.
By the way, this is one reason why some mission boards have branded me as being “anti-missionary.” Why is exposing the truth considered “anti” and hiding the truth “pro?” I have known some missionaries, whom I feel were worthy of $20,000 a month because I knew how productive they were and that they would use the funds to expand their ministry—not for personal gratification.
Some reading this book will immediately determine that missionaries make too much, and in many cases, they would be correct. To be fair, you need to understand, however, that missionaries are like you. Wherever we live, we want the best circumstances we can have for our family, including a good education, health care, comfort, etc. And logically, if all we have to do is ask for it, with no proof of success required to show that we are worthy of the sum, then why not ask? And if churches will give it, why not take it? The problem is, we have come to expect and demand the things that previous generations considered luxuries as necessities. And that applies to those pastors and laypeople living in America as well.
I do not think that a missionary should be poor or expected to live in poverty. If a pastor can have a house and a car, why can’t a missionary? However, one crucial consideration is that the pastor’s members, not the missionary’s converts, are the ones paying for the missionary’s car. But that’s another conundrum that I will address later, so I will leave it alone for now.
I have known a few missionaries who intentionally lived like the poor. I have no problem with that mindset because they later realize that all the people are not poor. From experience, I have learned that if you do this, the poor people, knowing you are from a wealthy land, will think you are crazy for living in a slum or a dangerous area when you could live elsewhere. They may respect you sooner or later, but initially, they will think you are crazy, a loser, or mentally deranged. On the other hand, the rich will shun you because of where you live, how poorly you dress, etc. Paul addressed this when he said he had become all things to all men. I would recommend living in a middle-class surrounding so you can reach down to the poor and up to the rich, being accepted and respected by both.
God help the man who, for lack of finances, will not go where God leads him or do what God tells him to do. God bless the missionaries who use “their support” to help the low-income families in their churches, build schools and church facilities, pay medical bills for others, and save for the travel expenses of the mandatory furlough every four to five years. Consider, if a small missionary family of five has to pay $1500 round-trip airplane tickets for each family member every five years. That need would require an extra $1500 a year—an extra $125 of monthly support to be raised and set aside for airline tickets. This amount does not include the travel and lodging costs they will incur once they arrive, and remember, during their year on furlough, they still have to pay rent on their house in the foreign land and the required utilities. The bills add up.
I don’t care how much a missionary makes. I only care about how much he accomplishes. I have known some salesmen who were worthy of a million-dollar salary and others who weren’t worth a thousand. It’s not the size of the family, the location on the planet, or the missionary’s oratorical skills that should determine how much he earns; it is his worth. And frankly, such worth cannot be determined by his age, intellect, or prior home-based ministry status. It can only be determined by how productive he is once he gets on the field. This is another reason to require lengthy internships in the field before being classified or supported as a missionary.
Few men are productive in their first term. During this time, they are getting acclimated to the weather, culture, and language, and until this is accomplished, they are the blind trying to lead the seeing. By the end of their second or third year, however, you should have an idea about the man’s value. That is why I recommend the first term be spent, not just with a veteran missionary, but with veteran national pastors.
In the American culture, being a veteran merely means having spent time at some task. I don’t see it that way. I have met many men who have been on the field for thirty years and have never discipled a single convert, never produced a single preacher, and never started a single church. By veteran, I mean a man who has accomplished what he was sent to accomplish. He was not sent to just pastor old sheep but to birth new lambs, plant churches, train men for the ministry and work himself out of a job continually so that he has to move elsewhere and start over.
We need to remember that since a novice missionary will likely become like the missionary who mentored him, he needs to be discipled by someone who has himself excelled. The Bible says that we produce after our own kind. That principle applies to birds, animals, and missionaries.
This brings me to the next part of the conundrum—why do novice missionaries make as much and sometimes more than veteran missionaries?
The answer? That’s the way it has always been done. Is it right? No. Is it fair? No. Is it productive? No. It just is. But I argue that it should not be and doesn’t have to be.
I am only one man, but I have an opinion, having served as a youth pastor, an assistant pastor, an associate pastor, and a senior pastor for twelve years before becoming a missionary. When moving necessitated my joining the staff at a different church, I didn’t make as much as the other staff who had been there for years before I arrived. Later, as a young, inexperienced pastor, I did not earn as much as the pastors of larger churches nor as much as the older pastors of small churches nor did I expect to. Why should I? But when it comes to missions, we give every missionary the same amount. Why is that?
Probably because the churches are not hiring us, they are helping us. Missionary—let that sink in for a moment. The church has the right to give whatever they want to whoever they want. It is up to God to lead them otherwise. My point in bringing it up is simply as an issue of stewardship. How so?
Statistically, we know that as much as 43 percent of the “missionaries” who start on deputation will never finish it. In a month, six months, two years or more, they will determine it was not God’s will and throw in the towel. I respect such men. In my mind, they wanted to serve the Lord and mistook a burden for a call (we have all done that), and once they realized it, they swallowed their pride, admitted their error, and started serving again as a layman in their home church or as a pastor. They undoubtedly learned a lot on the journey, and the churches they visited were hopefully blessed and encouraged by their presentations. However, the problem is that collectively, literally MILLIONS of missions’ dollars were wasted in their years of discovery.
Frankly, of those who do make it to the field, another 75 percent quit and go home in the first three years. But that’s another story for another time.
The solution in my mind is that the family and the home church send the missionary candidate to the field first for three to six months, so he sees what life will be like, experiencing the weather, the food, the language, the culture, and the difficulty of life in that land. Send him, his wife and family. Immerse them in the experience. Many will come home after only a few weeks when the thrill wears off, so it won’t have cost or wasted that much. But if a family makes it through, at least you have an idea that he can make it for the long term. (I say “family” because usually the wife is the one who cannot adapt to the missionary life.)
Then let him begin his deputation with a little experience under his belt—not just a two-week “survey trip.” I also recommend they stay on their own in a less-than-adequate environment, so they get the full experience. If they spend their time in a missionary’s home, the mall, and coffee shops, they might as well have stayed home. This experience should be their “boot camp,” proving their ability to adapt, adjust and achieve.
If the volume in numbers of missionaries supported is not your goal, I encourage churches to invest more heavily in men who have proven themselves for one term, two, or more. These men are not going to quit; they have proven there is no risk in the funds invested in them. Like consider supporting the national preachers; they already know the culture, the customs, the language, and the people. They have already gone through the heavy winds of ministry and even the storm’s eye and come out the other side victoriously. They are veterans with experience and success under their belts, with the churches they have started, the preachers they have trained, and the schools they have founded while still having the energy to do more. Why waste his time with another year-long furlough? Keep him on the field doing what he does best. Give him a raise in his support.
Doesn’t that sound at least a little bit logical?
Now, I realize that some churches simply want to see how many men they can support in how many places. If that’s what you’re all about, then go for it. God gets the glory either way. My suggestion is only given so that what you give will impact more lives. I’m all about numbers. Final Friends now has over 28,000 preachers in our network. However, not some, not most, but every man we support is a church planter. Every man we support had already proven himself with years of ministry. He had trained men for the ministry and had personally started at least two churches before we even began to consider him for support. I love the idea of quantity, but I adore the value of quality.
Some will think I am writing this book so that I can get more support. You have wrongly judged me. We have over seven thousand subscribers on our mailing list, and very few “support” my family and me. However, thousands support our preachers, children, etc. (This is because in over 35 years as a missionary, I have never done deputation.) Of those who support me, most are friends, not churches, so my logic doesn’t apply to them; thus, it does not benefit me.
I share said all this because I have both a forum to say it and the respect of pastors, churches, and laypeople to listen. I’m trying to help you consider possible improvements for your mission program so that collectively, we can all do more to advance the preaching of the gospel to places where it has never been preached before.
Eliminating the Conundrum
Suggestions for Missionaries Regarding Acquiring Support
- Remember that no church owes you support; they chose to give it because they believe in your intention to perform mighty exploits for God. Don’t let them down. And remember, they are not supporting you until they are supporting you. The late John R. Rice used to say, “Talk is cheap; it takes money to buy whiskey.” I have often wondered why he used that expression and how he knew, but it was comical to hear him say it. The point is, don’t count on promises for support. Remember Proverbs 13:12 says, “Hope deferred maketh the heart sick: but when the desire cometh, it is a tree of life.” Often when a church affirms support, they are expressing an intention and not stating a promise.
Suggestions for Churches:
When you tell a missionary, you are going to support him, do it. To do otherwise is to lie. Let him know the following:
- How much you will give
- How often you will give it
- When you will begin his support
In this way, he can make his budget and not be concerned that you have forgotten him.
Suggestions for Missionaries Regarding Maintaining Support:
- Don’t fail to report your progress and your difficulties regularly. Be honest.
- Share a testimony of a convert, not just a statistic,
- Include photos.
- Share the reasons behind your prayer requests.
Information is vital. If you cannot take the time every three months to write a letter, then why do you expect your supporting churches should take the time every month to write you a check?
- When told you will be taken on for support, show proper gratitude but remember that what you expect to happen tomorrow may take close to a year to be fulfilled. Why? Because churches work on a yearly budget, even when using Faith Promise. Perhaps their “new year” starts in January, and you are at their church in March. When the pastor says, “We are going to support you,” that probably means the support will start next January. This means you won’t get your first check until February, unless they pay quarterly, in which case it won’t arrive until April—over a year later!
- This being the case, it is perfectly acceptable for you to ask the pastor when the support will begin. Put that date on your calendar, and a few months before that date, send the pastor a gentle note, letting him know how much you are looking forward to their support coming and what a benefit it will be for your family and ministry. Maybe even share with him how you will be using his support. By doing this, he is not simply a supporter of your ministry; he is a partner with your ministry.
Suggestions for Churches
- Remember that you are his partner in ministry—not his silent partner. You are an investor who needs to be kept informed of his progress and setbacks. Read the letters and hold the missionary accountable to perform as expected. If he does not, reevaluate his support with him. Maybe you can help him improve but keep in mind if he is not yet a mature minister, he should be back home becoming one—not on the field, hoping to become one while setting an improper example for others.
- Let the missionary know what you expect from him. Do you want a letter monthly or quarterly? Can he send it by email or just give you a link to his Facebook postings? Is there something that he or his wife or family can do to help you boost mission giving and participation? Try not to condemn the missionary for not answering questions that you never asked.
- Pastors, please avoid questionaries. They can be a legitimate tool, but most missionaries have 80-to-100 supporting churches. If each one requires a unique questionnaire, then you have crippled his ministry. Imagine if each member of your church required that from you—and now having done so, “do unto others as you would have them do unto you.”
- New pastors, please don’t be so eager to undo what the church voted to do under your predecessor. It is common for a new pastor to want to wipe the missionary slate clean, keeping only those who went to his school or are from his favorite board. Just because you have never heard of some of these men does not mean they are not worthy. They have probably not heard of you either. We say that we believe in the local church’s autonomy, but often a new pastor disregards the decisions prayed over, made, and adopted by the church before he arrived. That is not biblical, and it’s not even logical. From time to time, I get a letter or even a phone call from a new pastor wanting to introduce himself and get to know me. That is a blessing and accomplishes what the pastor needed to make him feel comfortable with the missionaries his new church has been supporting. Later, if you begin to have questions or doubts, as a pastor, you have the right and the requirement to investigate and come to a decision about that missionary’s support.
Support this work
Your gift helps Final Frontiers Foundation equip missionaries and national preachers to reach people who have never heard the Gospel.













